Book an appointment

Knee

Do I need surgery for a meniscus tear, or is physiotherapy enough?

Do I need surgery for a meniscus tear, or is physiotherapy enough?

Many meniscus tears are treated without surgery.

Reviewed by Dr. Ramneek Mahajan

This guide was written and clinically reviewed by Dr Ramneek Mahajan. He is Chairman of Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement and Chief Robotic Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket. He performs keyhole knee surgery, including meniscus repair and trimming. He did advanced training (fellowships) at hospitals in Singapore, Australia and Germany.

For his full record, see the credentials page. For press coverage, see In the news.

~16 min read

· Last reviewed:

The answer

Often, physiotherapy is enough. For the common wear-and-tear tear, trials did not find keyhole trimming better than physiotherapy. Surgery is needed when a torn piece locks the knee. It may help when catching or locking keeps coming back after physiotherapy. Some tears in the outer rim, which has a blood supply, can be stitched.

In short

A meniscus tear does not always need surgery. There are two main kinds of tear. Tears from an injury are often in younger people. Wear-and-tear (degenerative) tears usually start in middle age. For wear-and-tear tears, physiotherapy usually comes first. Surgery is mainly for a locked knee, or a tear that can be stitched. It may also help when catching keeps coming back after physiotherapy. A repair keeps the cushion but takes longer to recover from than a trim.

Do I need surgery for a meniscus tear, or is physiotherapy enough?

This guide is for an adult with a meniscus tear, found on a scan or suspected after a twist. It is also for anyone with an ache along the side of the knee, or a knee that catches. If your knee is locked and will not straighten fully, see an orthopaedic doctor quickly. If a torn piece is blocking the knee, it usually needs surgery.

Who it is not for

This guide is not for someone whose knee pain comes mainly from advanced arthritis, or who needs a knee replacement. It also does not replace an examination of your knee by a doctor.

01

What is a meniscus tear?

Each knee has two menisci (one is a meniscus). They are curved, tough, rubbery pads between the thigh bone and the shin bone. The inner one is shaped like the letter C, and the outer one is closer to a ring.

Two soft rubber pads cushion one block on another: the menisci absorb shocks and help keep the knee steady.

They work as shock absorbers, and they help keep the knee steady.

The thigh bone presses down on the two cushions between the thigh bone and the shin bone. Then a tear opens in one of them.

AI generated. Representative only.

A tear means one of these pads is damaged. The kind of tear matters. It largely decides whether surgery is needed at all.

These signs point to a meniscus tear:

  • Pain along the joint line, the side of the knee where the bones meet

  • Swelling that comes and goes

  • Catching, clicking, or the knee giving way

  • A knee that locks and will not straighten fully. This matters most, because it can mean a torn piece is caught in the joint. Soon after an injury, swelling and tight muscles can also stop the knee straightening. A doctor checks which it is.

In a bucket-handle tear, a long strip of the meniscus splits and flips into the middle of the knee.

AI generated. Representative only.

Catching can also come from arthritis itself, and giving way from a torn ligament or weak thigh muscles. The doctor checks for these too.

A doctor checks where the knee is tender. They also do movement tests, such as the McMurray test. In it, the doctor bends and turns your knee to feel for a click or pain.

On their own, these tests suggest a tear but do not prove it. An X-ray is usually taken too. It does not show the meniscus, but it shows arthritis and other problems that can feel like a tear.

An MRI scan is very accurate: around 98 percent for tears of the inner (medial) meniscus. In older knees, wear inside the meniscus can look like a tear on the scan. So the doctor matches the scan with your symptoms and the examination.

A man gets up from a low kitchen seat, a hand at his knee: an ache after squatting can be a sign.

02

Do you need surgery for a meniscus tear?

For most people, especially with a wear-and-tear tear, surgery is probably not the first step. The research on this is unusually clear.

What do the trials show?

Careful studies (randomised trials) and reviews have looked at wear-and-tear tears with knee pain. They compared two treatments. One is keyhole surgery to trim the torn part (arthroscopic partial meniscectomy). The other is a course of physiotherapy.

They found no clear difference in pain or knee function at one and two years.

So surgery is not the automatic answer. Surgeons consider it in three situations:

  1. A locked knee. A torn piece, often a bucket-handle tear, has flipped into the middle of the knee and jams the joint. The knee will not straighten fully. Here, surgery should not wait.

  2. Catching or locking that keeps coming back. The knee still catches, locks or keeps swelling up after a fair trial of physiotherapy. Here, removing the torn piece may help.

  3. A tear that can be stitched, usually in a younger, active person. Most often a fresh tear in the outer rim of the meniscus, which has a blood supply. Stitching it keeps the cushion. Only about 10 to 15 percent of tears can be repaired like this.

One kind of wear-and-tear tear is handled differently. It is a tear at the root, where the back of the meniscus is fixed to the shin bone.

Some people feel a sudden painful pop at the back of the knee, for example when stepping up.

Left alone, this tear tends to do poorly. A surgeon may advise stitching the root back to the bone. This suits a younger, active person with little or no arthritis in the knee. The legs should not bend outwards or inwards at the knee.

If none of these fits you, structured physiotherapy is a sound first choice, backed by research. It is not a way of putting off treatment.

Path

What it is

When it tends to fit

Physiotherapy (no surgery)

A guided programme to build strength in the muscles of the thigh and hip, with some change in activity

Wear-and-tear tears. A knee that aches but does not lock. Often the first step for people over 40

Meniscus repair (stitching)

Keyhole stitching of a tear in the outer rim, which has a blood supply. It keeps the cushion.

A tear that can be repaired, usually in a younger, active person, often with an ACL reconstruction

Partial meniscectomy (a trim)

Keyhole removal of only the torn, loose part, keeping the healthy meniscus

A locked knee, or catching that has not got better, when the tear cannot be repaired

If an ACL tear is part of your injury, read about ACL tears too.

We push patients to do physiotherapy, because we want their muscles to remain active and healthy.

Dr Ramneek Mahajan

03

What does surgery involve: a repair or a trim?

Meniscus surgery is keyhole (arthroscopic) surgery. The surgeon works through small cuts, with a camera and fine instruments. It is usually a day-care operation.

One pad stitched along a split, one with its torn piece cut away: a repair keeps the meniscus, a trim removes part.

There are two very different operations, and which one you have matters for your knee's future.

04

How long is recovery after meniscus surgery?

Recovery depends on which operation you have. Before you agree to surgery, ask your surgeon which one you will likely have. Ask what its recovery looks like too.

Two calendars: after a trim, recovery takes weeks; after a repair, it takes months.

After the operation, go to the nearest hospital emergency at once if you have any of these:

  • new pain, swelling or tenderness in the calf (the back of the leg below the knee)

  • sudden breathlessness, chest pain or a racing heart

  • a fever above 38°C (100.4°F), or shivering

  • the knee becomes hot, red and more swollen

  • fluid leaking from the wound, or redness spreading from it

  • pain that suddenly gets worse after it had been getting better

  • severe pain that does not get better, even with the pain medicines you were given

  • you suddenly cannot put weight on the leg, after you had been able to

Go there first, and do not wait for the next appointment. After that, call the surgeon's team. If you do not have their number, the clinic page has a WhatsApp link to them. Call them about anything else that worries you too.

05

How do you choose a surgeon for a meniscus tear?

Five checks help you choose a surgeon for a meniscus tear.

A doctor shows both paths, physiotherapy and surgery, so you get clear advice on whether you need surgery at all.
  1. Training and position.

    Where did the surgeon train, for example in advanced training (fellowships) at well-known hospitals? What post do they hold at a well-known hospital? Look also for specialist qualifications (board certifications), teaching posts, roles in medical societies, and whether they train other surgeons.

  2. Clear advice on whether you need surgery at all.

    For a wear-and-tear tear, the right surgeon may suggest physiotherapy first. That is a good sign, not a weak one.

  3. Repair first, where a repair is possible.

    A surgeon who tries to keep the meniscus, rather than trim it first, is thinking about your knee's future.

  4. Keyhole knee experience.

    Meniscus surgery is keyhole surgery. Choose a surgeon who does keyhole knee surgery regularly.

  5. Physiotherapy support.

    With surgery or without it, the strengthening programme is a large part of the result. Ask what physiotherapy support the practice gives.

Who is Dr Ramneek Mahajan?

Dr Ramneek Mahajan is Chairman of Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement and Chief Robotic Joint Replacement. He works at Max Smart Super Speciality Hospital, Saket. He performs keyhole meniscus surgery there, both repair and trimming. He did advanced training (fellowships) at Singapore General Hospital, The Prince Charles Hospital in Brisbane, and Puttlingen Hospital in Germany.

You can check his training and roles on his credentials page.

Every patient is personally assessed by Dr Ramneek, even when seen by the team - this may add to OPD waiting times, but ensures the doctor's direct evaluation in your case.

06

How much does meniscus treatment cost?

The cost depends on the path you take. Physiotherapy is a course of sessions over several weeks. For surgery, the cost depends on whether it is a repair or a trim. It also depends on the type of hospital and your own situation. No single amount fits everyone.

A screwdriver on a screw and a spanner on a bolt: physiotherapy and surgery each fit a different problem.
Right tool for each job.

For many wear-and-tear tears, the lower-cost path, physiotherapy, is also the right medical first step. The less costly choice and the right choice are often the same.

But they are not always the same. Surgery is needed when a torn piece locks the knee. Where a repair is possible, it is usually better for the knee in the long term.

For your own cost estimate and insurance cover, ask Dr Ramneek Mahajan's team at or after your first consultation.

Arthroscopic surgery is like a laparoscopy. It is keyhole surgery.

Dr Ramneek Mahajan

07

Does meniscus surgery work, and what can go wrong?

When surgery is really needed, it usually helps. That means a locked knee, or a tear that can be repaired. It may also help with catching or locking that keeps coming back. The caution is about surgery that is not needed, and about the long term.

What can surgery not promise?

For a wear-and-tear tear, trimming has not been shown to beat physiotherapy. In a study of one kind of wear-and-tear tear, at the root, trimming also did not slow the arthritis. An operation on a wear-and-tear tear can leave you no better off.

  • Trimming has a long-term cost. The meniscus protects the joint. Removing part of it puts more load on the smooth lining of the joint (cartilage). Over the years, this is linked with wear in the joint. The more that is removed, the greater the wear. That is why keeping tissue matters.

  • A repair needs patience, and it can fail. A stitched meniscus does not always heal, and recovery takes months, not weeks. When it heals, it protects the knee. Rarely, the stitching injures a nerve near the knee. This can cause numbness, or weakness when lifting the foot. When a repair is done together with an ACL reconstruction, the knee is more likely to become stiff.

  • Surgery has the usual small risks of any keyhole operation. The most common are infection and a clot in a leg vein. They are uncommon, but real. That is one more reason not to operate on a knee that does not need it.

This is not a reason to avoid surgery that is really needed. It is a reason to be sure first.

A mended cricket pad strapped and ready beside a bat: when surgery is really needed, it usually helps.

Have a meniscus tear, or think you might? The next step is a first consultation with Dr Ramneek Mahajan. It starts with whether you need surgery at all.

He looks at your scan, your symptoms and your goals. Then you and he agree a clear plan: physiotherapy, a repair or a trim, whichever your knee needs.

The button below shows when and where he sees patients.

An assessment first. Surgery only if you need it.

Questions people ask

Some meniscus tears can heal, depending on where they are. Small, fresh tears in the outer rim can heal if they do not move out of place. That part has a blood supply. This sometimes needs a period of protection. Tears in the inner part, which has little blood supply, usually do not heal. But they often become comfortable enough with physiotherapy that they stop causing trouble. So "it won't fully heal" does not mean "it needs surgery".

Trimming can raise the risk. The meniscus protects the joint surface. Removing part of it puts more load on the cartilage, the smooth lining of the joint. The more that is removed, the greater the effect. This is not a reason to fear a trim when it is really needed. But it is a strong reason not to trim a tear that would do just as well with physiotherapy.

Who is telling you this?

This guide was written and clinically reviewed by Dr Ramneek Mahajan. He is Chairman of Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement and Chief Robotic Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket. He performs keyhole knee surgery, including meniscus repair and trimming. He did advanced training (fellowships) at hospitals in Singapore, Australia and Germany.

For his full record, see the credentials page. For press coverage, see In the news.

Where to See Dr. Ramneek Mahajan

Wherever you come, you see him personally.

Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Saket, New Delhi
Monday to Saturday
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Greater Kailash 1, New Delhi
Wednesday & Friday
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details

Next 3 Days

17 November, TuesdayToday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
18 November, Wednesday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Available at GK-1
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
19 November, Thursday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Where to See Dr. Ramneek Mahajan

Wherever you come, you see him personally.

Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Saket, New Delhi
Monday to Saturday
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Greater Kailash 1, New Delhi
Wednesday & Friday
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details

Next 3 Days

17 November, TuesdayToday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
18 November, Wednesday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Available at GK-1
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
19 November, Thursday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Where to See Dr. Ramneek Mahajan

Wherever you come, you see him personally.

Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Saket, New Delhi
Monday to Saturday
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Greater Kailash 1, New Delhi
Wednesday & Friday
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details

Next 3 Days

17 November, TuesdayToday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
18 November, Wednesday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Available at GK-1
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
19 November, Thursday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM

Dr. Ramneek Mahajan is Chairman Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement & Chief Robotic Joint Replacement at Max Smart Super Speciality Hospital, Saket. His practice has completed 18,000+ joint replacements and 2,000+ robotic procedures since 2022 - the first MAKO program adopted in Delhi. Senior colleagues refer when their primary work needs revision.

Clinical content on this site was last reviewed on 20 October 2026 by Dr. Ramneek Mahajan, Chairman of Orthopaedics and Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket.
This site is for scheduled care.

Dr. Ramneek Mahajan is Chairman Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement & Chief Robotic Joint Replacement at Max Smart Super Speciality Hospital, Saket. His practice has completed 18,000+ joint replacements and 2,000+ robotic procedures since 2022 - the first MAKO program adopted in Delhi. Senior colleagues refer when their primary work needs revision.

Clinical content on this site was last reviewed on 20 October 2026 by Dr. Ramneek Mahajan, Chairman of Orthopaedics and Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket.
This site is for scheduled care.

Dr. Ramneek Mahajan is Chairman Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement & Chief Robotic Joint Replacement at Max Smart Super Speciality Hospital, Saket. His practice has completed 18,000+ joint replacements and 2,000+ robotic procedures since 2022 - the first MAKO program adopted in Delhi. Senior colleagues refer when their primary work needs revision.

Clinical content on this site was last reviewed on 20 October 2026 by Dr. Ramneek Mahajan, Chairman of Orthopaedics and Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket.
This site is for scheduled care.

Powered by RAiZEN · Built in India, for the world · © 2026 RAiZEN
Go to RAiZEN website