Book an appointment

Knee

Do I need surgery for an ACL tear, or can my knee work well without it?

Do I need surgery for an ACL tear, or can my knee work well without it?

Many torn ACLs are managed without surgery.

Reviewed by Dr. Ramneek Mahajan

This guide was written and clinically reviewed by Dr Ramneek Mahajan. He is Chairman of Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement and Chief Robotic Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket. He performs keyhole knee surgery, including ACL reconstruction. He did advanced training (fellowships) at hospitals in Singapore, Australia and Germany.

For his full record, see the credentials page. For press coverage, see In the news.

~15 min read

· Last reviewed:

The answer

Not always. In one study, about 6 in 10 people with a torn ACL managed without surgery. Many still had some symptoms. Without surgery, you follow a planned exercise programme and change some activities. Surgery is usually advised when the knee keeps giving way, or for sports with sudden turns. Many people can try about three months of rehab first.

In short

A torn ACL does not always need surgery. Many people manage with structured rehabilitation (rehab) and some change in activity. Surgery is usually for knees that keep giving way, and for people set on returning to sports with sudden turns. It may also be advised when a torn meniscus that can be stitched is found with the ACL tear. Three questions help decide it. How unsteady is the knee? What do you want to get back to? How does the knee do after about three months of rehab?

Do I need surgery for an ACL tear, or can my knee work well without it?

This guide is for an active adult who has torn an ACL, or thinks they have. If you play a sport with sudden turns, or your knee keeps giving way, surgery is a real question. If the knee feels steady in daily life, you have more time to decide than many people think.

Who it is not for

This guide is not for someone whose main problem is knee arthritis, or who needs a knee replacement. It also does not replace an examination of your knee by a doctor.

01

What is an ACL tear?

The ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) is a strong band inside the knee. It runs through the middle of the joint and joins the thigh bone to the shin bone.

A gate hangs loose after its strap snaps: with a torn ACL the knee can feel loose, and for some it gives way on a turn.

It stops the shin bone sliding forward, and it keeps the knee steady when you turn or twist. It does most of the first job on its own. Roughly 85 percent of the resistance to the shin sliding forward comes from the ACL. When the ACL tears, the knee can feel loose, and for some people it gives way on a turn.

The ACL is a strong band in the middle of the knee. It joins the thigh bone to the shin bone. Here the knee twists.

AI generated. Representative only.

An ACL tear usually happens during a twisting movement. These signs point to it:

  • A twist, a landing or a sudden stop, often with no one touching you

  • A pop, felt or heard, at the moment of injury

  • Swelling within a few hours, not days

  • A feeling that the knee gave way, or may give way again on a turn

  • Difficulty carrying on with the game or activity

The knee twists too far, and the ACL in the middle of the joint tears.

AI generated. Representative only.

When this pattern is present, the chance of an ACL tear is high: over 70 percent in published studies.

A doctor confirms it with an examination. A simple hand test in the clinic, the Lachman test, picks up about 95 percent of ACL tears. An MRI scan confirms the tear. It also shows any other damage. This could be to the meniscus (a rubbery cushion inside the knee) or to the joint's smooth lining (cartilage).

Go to the nearest hospital emergency at once if the knee looks out of place. Do the same if the foot goes cold, pale, numb or blue, or you cannot move the foot or toes.

Get any knee checked that pops and swells fast after a twist. See a doctor promptly if:

  • The knee locks, or cannot straighten fully. A piece of torn meniscus may be caught in the joint.

  • The knee gives way again and again, so walking or taking stairs feels unsafe.

  • The knee swells badly straight away, and you cannot put weight on it.

A young player sits out on the bench with ice on his knee while the game goes on.

02

Do you need surgery for an ACL tear?

An ACL tear has two main paths. One is structured rehabilitation (rehab): a planned exercise programme with a physiotherapist. The other is an operation to rebuild the ligament, called ACL reconstruction. Surgery is one path, not the automatic answer.

Path

What it is

When it tends to work

What it asks of you

Rehab (no surgery)

Strength, balance and control work for the thigh muscles, with a physiotherapist. Some change to sports with sudden turns

The knee is steady in daily life. You do not plan to go back to sports with sudden turns. The knee improves over about three months of rehab.

Regular rehab work, and a clear choice about which activities you will change

ACL reconstruction (surgery)

A keyhole operation that replaces the torn ligament with a graft. The graft is usually a strip of your own tendon, from the back of the thigh or near the kneecap. A tendon is the cord that joins a muscle to a bone.

The knee keeps giving way. You want to go back to sports with sudden turns or contact. Rehab has not made the knee steady. A torn meniscus that can be stitched is found with the ACL tear.

A graft, a recovery of several months, and rehab either way

Who needs surgery, and who does well without it?

Many people do well without reconstruction. One well-known long-term study followed people whose knees were found to be loose on testing. About 6 in 10 managed their ACL injury without it, though many still had some symptoms. A smaller group had surgery early, and another group needed it later.

Three things, known early, point towards surgery:

  1. Younger age, with years of active sport ahead

  2. Many hours of sport before the injury, especially sports with sudden turns

  3. A looser knee at the first examination: the shin moves further forward than normal when the doctor tests it

If none of these is strongly true for you, rehab is a sound first choice. If all three are true, reconstruction is more likely to be the answer. Most people are somewhere in between, so the decision is made with your surgeon, not by a formula.

Often, yes, and studies support it. In one long-term study of athletes, everyone first did about three months of rehab. Only those whose knee stayed unsteady went on to surgery. After 20 years, knee arthritis was no different between those who stayed with rehab and those who had surgery.

So a rehab-first trial is a reasonable plan for many people. But waiting is not the same as ignoring the knee. If your knee keeps giving way while you stay active, each episode can damage the meniscus and cartilage over time. That later damage raises the risk of arthritis.

The smooth, white cartilage on the end of the thigh bone slowly wears away. Rough bone is left. This is the wear of arthritis.

AI generated. Representative only.

So the plan is active rehab with a clear date to review the knee. If a meniscus tear is part of your injury, read about meniscus tears too.

For ACL surgery, the rehabilitation starts from the day of surgery itself.

Dr Ramneek Mahajan

03

What happens during ACL reconstruction?

ACL reconstruction is keyhole (arthroscopic) surgery. The surgeon usually does not stitch the torn ligament back together, because a stitched ligament often does not hold. Instead, the torn ligament is replaced with a graft. Over months, the graft becomes the knee's new ACL.

A boot with a new lace through the same holes: the torn ACL is usually replaced with a strip of your own tendon.

The operation is usually done once the early swelling has gone down and the knee moves well again. It is not done in a rush in the first days after the injury.

04

What is recovery like, and when can you return to sport?

Recovery after ACL reconstruction usually comes in stages, and it takes months, not weeks. The early stage protects the new graft and brings back full movement. The middle stage builds strength. The last stage trains the knee for sport. Rushing any stage raises the risk to the new graft.

One sports bag packed three times: recovery after ACL surgery comes in stages over months, with sport last.

After the operation, go to the nearest hospital emergency at once if you have any of these:

  • new pain, swelling or tenderness in the calf (the back of the leg below the knee)

  • sudden breathlessness, chest pain or a racing heart

  • a fever above 38°C (100.4°F), or shivering

  • the knee becomes hot, red and more swollen

  • fluid leaking from the wound, or redness spreading from it

  • pain that suddenly gets worse after it had been getting better

  • severe pain that does not get better, even with the pain medicines you were given

  • you suddenly cannot put weight on the leg, after you had been able to

Go there first, and do not wait for the next appointment. After that, call the surgeon's team. If you do not have their number, the clinic page has a WhatsApp link to them. Call them about anything else that worries you too.

What our patients say on Google about recovery

Ayush Srivastava

Knee Replacement
on
29 January 2026

However, this year while playing football, I re-tore the ACL in the same leg along with my lateral meniscus.

ExpertisePhysiotherapyRecovery Experience

Ayush Srivastava

Knee Replacement
on
29 January 2026

However, this year while playing football, I re-tore the ACL in the same leg along with my lateral meniscus.

ExpertisePhysiotherapyRecovery Experience

MOHAMEDEK A. MOHAMUD

Knee Replacement
on Doctor replied
1 June 2025

I came from somalia for my acl surgery by dr ramneek mahajan he is very good and his team with physios helped at every step.

ExpertiseNursing CarePhysiotherapy

MOHAMEDEK A. MOHAMUD

Knee Replacement
on Doctor replied
1 June 2025

I came from somalia for my acl surgery by dr ramneek mahajan he is very good and his team with physios helped at every step.

ExpertiseNursing CarePhysiotherapy

Allamyrat Kakamyradowich

Knee Replacement
on Doctor replied
31 May 2025

I had an high grade ACL torn and Dr. Mahajan did the surgery.

Follow Up CareSurgical Outcome

Allamyrat Kakamyradowich

Knee Replacement
on Doctor replied
31 May 2025

I had an high grade ACL torn and Dr. Mahajan did the surgery.

Follow Up CareSurgical Outcome

05

How do you choose a surgeon for an ACL tear?

Five checks help you choose a surgeon for an ACL tear.

A doctor shows both paths, rehab or surgery: a good surgeon tells you plainly if you need surgery at all.
  1. Training and position.

    Where did the surgeon train, for example in advanced training (fellowships) at well-known hospitals? What post do they hold at a well-known hospital? Look also for board certifications, teaching posts, roles in medical societies, and whether they train other surgeons.

  2. Keyhole knee experience.

    ACL reconstruction is keyhole surgery. Choose a surgeon who does keyhole knee surgery regularly.

  3. Clear advice on whether you need surgery at all.

    The right surgeon tells you plainly if rehab is the better first step. They do not push an operation you may not need.

  4. Physiotherapy support.

    The result depends as much on the months of rehab as on the operation. Ask what physiotherapy support the practice gives.

  5. Follow-up.

    Choose a surgeon who keeps seeing you through the recovery, until you are back to your activity.

Who is Dr Ramneek Mahajan?

Dr Ramneek Mahajan is Chairman of Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement and Chief Robotic Joint Replacement. He works at Max Smart Super Speciality Hospital, Saket. He performs keyhole ACL reconstruction there. He did advanced training (fellowships) at Singapore General Hospital, The Prince Charles Hospital in Brisbane, and Puttlingen Hospital in Germany.

You can check his training and roles on his credentials page.

Every patient is personally assessed by Dr Ramneek, even when seen by the team - this may add to OPD waiting times, but ensures the doctor's direct evaluation in your case.

06

How much does ACL treatment cost?

The cost depends on which path you take. Rehab is a course of physiotherapy over several months. The cost of reconstruction depends on the graft, the type of hospital and your own situation. No single amount fits everyone.

A screwdriver on a screw and a spanner on a bolt: rehab and surgery each fit a different knee, and cost depends on the path.
Right tool for each job.

For some people, the lower-cost path is also the right medical choice. Your knee may be steady in daily life, and you may not be going back to sports with sudden turns. Then rehab can be the right first step, and also the less costly one.

For your own cost estimate and insurance cover, ask Dr Ramneek Mahajan's team at or after your first consultation.

Arthroscopic surgery is like a laparoscopy. It is keyhole surgery.

Dr Ramneek Mahajan

07

Does ACL surgery work, and what can go wrong?

ACL reconstruction is a common operation, and it works for most people who need it. It is not a guarantee. Studies give its results as ranges.

Football boots ready on a bench: ACL reconstruction works for most people who need it, and it is not a guarantee.

Torn an ACL, or think you have? The next step is a first consultation with Dr Ramneek Mahajan. It starts with whether you need surgery at all, not with booking an operation.

He looks at your knee and your goals. Then you get a clear plan: rehab, surgery, or rehab first with a date to review the knee.

An assessment first. Surgery only if you need it.

Real outcomes from real patients

Back on the football field after arthroscopic ACL reconstruction
ACL Reconstruction
Back on the football field after arthroscopic ACL reconstruction

These videos are published on Max Healthcare's official YouTube channel. Each patient's experience is unique - outcomes depend on individual health, disease characteristics, and clinical factors. These accounts are not a guarantee of results.

Questions people ask

Walking and straight-line running are often possible without an ACL, once the knee is strong and the swelling has gone. The missing ligament matters in sudden turns, twists and changes of direction. Those are the movements where the knee can give way. So the decision depends closely on the sport you want to return to.

Arthritis can develop later, and surgery does not fully prevent it. In long-term studies, arthritis appeared in a share of knees whether or not they were rebuilt. Damage to the meniscus and cartilage from repeated giving way raises the risk. So the goal is to keep the knee steady, by whichever path does that for you.

Who is telling you this?

This guide was written and clinically reviewed by Dr Ramneek Mahajan. He is Chairman of Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement and Chief Robotic Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket. He performs keyhole knee surgery, including ACL reconstruction. He did advanced training (fellowships) at hospitals in Singapore, Australia and Germany.

For his full record, see the credentials page. For press coverage, see In the news.

Where to See Dr. Ramneek Mahajan

Wherever you come, you see him personally.

Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Saket, New Delhi
Monday to Saturday
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Greater Kailash 1, New Delhi
Wednesday & Friday
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details

Next 3 Days

17 November, TuesdayToday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
18 November, Wednesday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Available at GK-1
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
19 November, Thursday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Where to See Dr. Ramneek Mahajan

Wherever you come, you see him personally.

Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Saket, New Delhi
Monday to Saturday
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Greater Kailash 1, New Delhi
Wednesday & Friday
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details

Next 3 Days

17 November, TuesdayToday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
18 November, Wednesday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Available at GK-1
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
19 November, Thursday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Where to See Dr. Ramneek Mahajan

Wherever you come, you see him personally.

Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Max SMART Super Speciality Hospital
Saket, New Delhi
Monday to Saturday
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Mahajan's Knee & Hip Centre
Greater Kailash 1, New Delhi
Wednesday & Friday
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
See location on Google Maps
See clinic details

Next 3 Days

17 November, TuesdayToday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
18 November, Wednesday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM
Available at GK-1
4:00 PM to 6:00 PM
19 November, Thursday
Available at Saket
12:00 PM to 4:00 PM

Dr. Ramneek Mahajan is Chairman Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement & Chief Robotic Joint Replacement at Max Smart Super Speciality Hospital, Saket. His practice has completed 18,000+ joint replacements and 2,000+ robotic procedures since 2022 - the first MAKO program adopted in Delhi. Senior colleagues refer when their primary work needs revision.

Clinical content on this site was last reviewed on 20 October 2026 by Dr. Ramneek Mahajan, Chairman of Orthopaedics and Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket.
This site is for scheduled care.

Dr. Ramneek Mahajan is Chairman Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement & Chief Robotic Joint Replacement at Max Smart Super Speciality Hospital, Saket. His practice has completed 18,000+ joint replacements and 2,000+ robotic procedures since 2022 - the first MAKO program adopted in Delhi. Senior colleagues refer when their primary work needs revision.

Clinical content on this site was last reviewed on 20 October 2026 by Dr. Ramneek Mahajan, Chairman of Orthopaedics and Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket.
This site is for scheduled care.

Dr. Ramneek Mahajan is Chairman Orthopaedics, Joint Replacement & Chief Robotic Joint Replacement at Max Smart Super Speciality Hospital, Saket. His practice has completed 18,000+ joint replacements and 2,000+ robotic procedures since 2022 - the first MAKO program adopted in Delhi. Senior colleagues refer when their primary work needs revision.

Clinical content on this site was last reviewed on 20 October 2026 by Dr. Ramneek Mahajan, Chairman of Orthopaedics and Joint Replacement, Max SMART Saket.
This site is for scheduled care.

Powered by RAiZEN · Built in India, for the world · © 2026 RAiZEN
Go to RAiZEN website